Inpex CCUS Projects, 10 Mtpa Darwin Plan, Kanto Natural Gas JV, and 4 Key Agreements (2021-2025)
Inpex Project Strategy: Asset Defense with CCS vs. Market Creation with DAC
In 2025, INPEX Corporation’s decarbonization strategy solidified around deploying large-scale Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) projects as a defensive measure to protect the economic viability of its core natural gas assets, a pragmatic approach that diverges from competitors pursuing market-facing Direct Air Capture (DAC) ventures. While prior years involved planning, 2025 saw INPEX advance tangible, multi-billion dollar CCS projects directly integrated with its LNG facilities, aiming to mitigate operational emissions rather than build new revenue streams from carbon removal credits.
INPEX Focus on Integrated CCS
The company’s actions in 2025 demonstrated a clear capital allocation priority toward point-source capture. This strategy leverages its extensive experience in complex engineering projects to de-risk its fossil fuel investments in a carbon-constrained world.
- Between 2021 and 2024, INPEX conducted foundational studies and planning for decarbonizing its major assets, particularly the Ichthys LNG project in Australia.
- In November 2025, this strategy culminated in a proposal for Australia’s largest CCS project near Darwin, a joint venture with Total Energies and Woodside designed to capture and store 8 to 10 million tonnes of CO₂ per annum (Mtpa), primarily from the Ichthys facility.
- Concurrently, INPEX initiated Front End Engineering and Design (FEED) for the Abadi LNG Project in Indonesia, framing CCS integration as a central element for creating a lower-carbon energy supply chain.
Competitor Divergence to Pure-Play DAC
While INPEX focused on its own emissions, other energy and technology firms pushed ahead with standalone DAC projects. This positions them to capitalize on the growing voluntary and compliance markets for carbon dioxide removal (CDR), a market INPEX is currently observing rather than actively building.
- This approach contrasts sharply with competitors like Occidental Petroleum, whose subsidiary 1 Point Five was on track in 2025 to launch its Stratos facility, a pure-play DAC plant designed to capture 500, 000 tonnes of CO₂ per year directly from the atmosphere.
- Similarly, energy producers like BKV Corporation have focused on creating integrated CCUS businesses to decarbonize the Texas energy grid.
- INPEX‘s official “Vision 2035” and technical roadmaps mention DAC as a future possibility, but its tangible 2025 project pipeline was exclusively centered on point-source CCS, indicating a follower position in the broader carbon removal technology space.
$1.3 B Competitor Benchmark, INPEX Capital Focus on Integrated Assets
While INPEX did not disclose project-specific investment figures in 2025, the sheer scale of its proposed CCS hubs implies multi-billion dollar commitments. The broader market context was defined by high-profile investments in pure-play DAC, such as Occidental’s Stratos project, which set a financial benchmark and highlighted the significant capital required to commercialize carbon removal technologies.
Occidental’s Stratos DAC Financing
The financing of the Stratos project established a clear precedent for funding large-scale DAC. Occidental’s success in attracting a major institutional investor signaled growing confidence in the commercial viability of the carbon removal market, independent of decarbonizing existing fossil fuel operations.
- The Stratos DAC facility, with a planned annual capture capacity of 500, 000 tonnes, carried a total investment of $1.3 billion and was on track for a mid-2025 launch.
- In a key validation for the sector, Black Rock committed $550 million through a joint venture to help build the Stratos plant, underscoring investor appetite for scalable climate technologies.
INPEX Implied Capital Allocation
INPEX‘s capital was strategically channeled into projects that directly support its core business. The investments are structured to preserve the value of its long-life LNG assets by addressing their carbon footprint, rather than to create a new, independent business line in carbon management.
- The proposed 10 Mtpa Darwin CCS hub and the CCS-integrated Abadi LNG project represent massive capital undertakings, with industry-wide benchmarks for related infrastructure running at a CAPEX rate of approximately $1, 549/k W.
- This capital allocation strategy aligns with that of industrial emitters in sectors like steel, where companies such as Tata Steel and JSW are exploring CCUS primarily to decarbonize existing production facilities.
Table: Key Carbon Management Investments and Benchmarks (2025)
| Partner / Project | Time Frame | Details and Strategic Purpose | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Occidental Petroleum / Black Rock | 2025 | Black Rock invested $550 million in a joint venture to develop the Stratos DAC plant. The project has a total cost of $1.3 billion and is designed to capture 500, 000 tonnes of CO₂ annually. | Innovation Map |
| Australian Government | July 2025 | Announced A$65 million in funding for seven Carbon Capture and Utilization (CCU) projects, including some focused on DAC and mineral carbonization, creating a supportive policy environment for projects in the region. | Norton Rose Fulbright |
| Industry Benchmark | 2025 | Technoeconomic analyses for related energy infrastructure established a CAPEX rate of $1, 549/k W and a fixed OPEX of $31/k W/yr, highlighting the high capital intensity of large-scale energy and CCS projects. | Science Direct |
INPEX 2 Strategic JVs to Build Regional Carbon Hubs (2025)
In 2025, INPEX executed a partnership-heavy strategy, forming key joint ventures to distribute the immense financial and operational risks of building regional CCS infrastructure. This collaborative model is essential for developing the large-scale CO₂ transport and storage hubs that underpin its decarbonization plans for Australia and Japan.
Darwin CCS Consortium
The proposed Darwin CCS hub is a cornerstone of INPEX‘s strategy to decarbonize its flagship Ichthys LNG asset. Partnering with other major energy players with a presence in the region was a critical step to advance the project from concept to a formal proposal.
- In November 2025, INPEX announced it was working with Total Energies and Woodside on a joint venture to develop the CCS project near Darwin.
- The project aims to create a multi-user hub with an initial capacity of 8 to 10 Mtpa, leveraging depleted gas fields for permanent CO₂ storage.
Metropolitan CCS, LTD.
To advance its domestic ambitions, INPEX established a partnership to explore and develop a CCS value chain serving one of Japan’s primary industrial and population centers. This move signals a strategy to replicate the hub model in different geographies.
- In April 2025, INPEX and Kanto Natural Gas Development established a joint venture named “Metropolitan CCS, LTD.”
- The venture’s purpose is to conduct studies and pursue the commercialization of CCS projects in the Tokyo metropolitan area, targeting emissions from hard-to-abate industries.
Table: INPEX Carbon Management Partnerships (2025)
| Partner / Project | Time Frame | Details and Strategic Purpose | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Energies, Woodside | Nov 2025 | Formed a consortium to develop a large-scale, multi-user CCS hub near Darwin, Australia, with a planned capacity of 8-10 Mtpa to service the Ichthys LNG project and other potential customers. | The Guardian |
| Kanto Natural Gas Development | Apr 2025 | Established a 50-50 joint venture, “Metropolitan CCS, LTD., ” to evaluate and commercialize a CCS value chain in the Kanto region, including the Tokyo metropolitan area. | Carbon Herald |
Australia and Japan: INPEX’s Geographic Focus for Carbon Hubs
INPEX‘s carbon management activities in 2025 were geographically anchored in Australia and Japan, two regions where the company operates major energy assets and where favorable geology and policy environments support the development of large-scale CCS infrastructure.
Australia as a CCS Epicenter
Australia became the clear center of gravity for INPEX‘s decarbonization efforts, driven by the urgent need to manage emissions from its massive Ichthys LNG facility. The country’s vast, well-understood geological formations offer significant potential for secure, long-term CO₂ storage.
- While the 2021-2024 period was marked by studies, 2025 saw concrete action with the formal proposal for the Darwin CCS hub and the submission of an environmental referral for the Bonaparte CCS project in October 2025.
- These projects are located in the Northern Territory, in close proximity to the Ichthys gas fields and processing facilities, minimizing CO₂ transportation costs and logistical complexity.
Japan as a Domestic Proving Ground
In its home market, INPEX focused on building an end-to-end domestic value chain for low-carbon energy. The initiatives in Japan serve as proving grounds for integrating hydrogen production with CCS, creating a blueprint for future projects.
- In June 2025, INPEX began commissioning Japan’s first blue hydrogen and ammonia project at the Kashiwazaki Clean Hydrogen/Ammonia Park in Niigata Prefecture, which includes an integrated CCUS component.
- The formation of the “Metropolitan CCS” joint venture in April 2025 further demonstrates a strategy to establish regional carbon management infrastructure to support industrial decarbonization within Japan.
CCS at Commercial Scale, INPEX DAC Initiatives Remain Exploratory
In 2025, INPEX‘s carbon management strategy was firmly grounded in technologically mature, commercial-scale CCS solutions to address its immediate emissions liabilities, while its engagement with the more novel field of Direct Air Capture remained in an early, exploratory stage.
CCS as a Bankable Technology
The company’s major project advancements in 2025 confirm its view of CCS as a de-risked and bankable technology ready for deployment at the massive scale required by its LNG operations. This approach prioritizes proven engineering over nascent, higher-risk technologies.
- The decision to advance the Abadi LNG Project to FEED with integrated CCS and the proposal for the 10 Mtpa Darwin hub signal confidence in the technical and commercial feasibility of large-scale point-source capture and storage.
- This reliance on established technology is common in capital-intensive industries, with companies like the modular capture provider Carbon Clean also focusing on proven solvent-based systems for industrial clients.
DAC in the Strategic Roadmapping Phase
Despite DAC’s inclusion in long-term corporate vision documents, INPEX‘s actions in 2025 showed no tangible investment in or deployment of the technology. This positions DAC as a long-term strategic option rather than a near-term capital priority.
- The broader DAC industry in 2025 was focused on advancing technologies from Technology Readiness Level (TRL) 5 toward TRL 8, with several companies operating or building large-scale pilots.
- INPEX announced no pilots, technology partnerships, or direct investments in DAC companies in 2025, suggesting it is a technology follower, waiting for costs to fall and operational models to be proven by more specialized players. The subsequent withdrawal of the Bonaparte CCS project from government assessment in early 2026 also highlights the significant execution risks that exist even for more mature CCS projects.
SWOT Analysis of INPEX’s Carbon Management Strategy
INPEX‘s 2025 carbon strategy leverages its core competency in large-scale project execution, representing a significant strength. However, this focus on defensive, asset-integrated CCS creates a potential weakness by ceding leadership in the high-growth, innovative DAC market to more agile competitors, exposing the company to long-term strategic threats.
Table: SWOT Analysis for INPEX Carbon Management Initiatives
| SWOT Category | 2021 – 2024 | 2025 | What Changed / Resolved / Validated |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strengths | Deep expertise in subsurface geology and large-scale energy project management. Strong balance sheet to fund capital-intensive projects. | Leveraged engineering expertise to propose the 10 Mtpa Darwin CCS hub and advance Abadi LNG with integrated CCS. | Validated that INPEX‘s core competency is its key strategic advantage, translating planning into concrete mega-project proposals. |
| Weaknesses | Limited demonstrated experience in novel carbon removal technologies like DAC. A reactive strategy focused on decarbonizing existing assets. | No announced pilots or investments in DAC technology, while competitors like Occidental advanced large-scale DAC plants. | The strategic gap in innovation widened in 2025, confirming INPEX as a follower, not a leader, in the broader carbon removal market. |
| Opportunities | Potential to become a key infrastructure owner for CO₂ storage in the Asia-Pacific region, serving third-party emitters. | Formed JVs for Darwin CCS (with Total Energies, Woodside) and Metropolitan CCS (with Kanto Gas) to build regional hubs. | INPEX actively pursued the storage infrastructure opportunity in 2025, moving to establish a first-mover advantage in key geographies. |
| Threats | Regulatory hurdles, cost overruns, and securing social license for mega-scale CCS projects. Competition from pure-play DAC providers. | Occidental’s $1.3 B Stratos DAC project materialized the competitive threat from non-integrated carbon removal business models. Bonaparte CCS project faced regulatory review. | The viability of the pure-play DAC model was validated by major investments, while the execution risk of INPEX‘s CCS strategy was highlighted by the subsequent Bonaparte project withdrawal in 2026. |
INPEX 2026 Outlook: Will Darwin CCS Advance or Face Bonaparte’s Fate?
The most critical variable for INPEX‘s decarbonization strategy in the year ahead is whether its flagship Darwin CCS proposal can successfully navigate the complex regulatory and commercial landscape that ultimately led to the withdrawal of its Bonaparte CCS project. The outcome will serve as a key validator or a major setback for the company’s entire asset-centric CCS approach.
- If this happens: INPEX and its partners secure key environmental approvals and a financial investment decision (FID) to move the Darwin CCS project into the full execution phase.
- Watch this: Announcements of new offtake agreements for CO₂ storage from third-party industrial emitters beyond the founding partners. Such deals would signal the project’s viability as a true multi-user hub and a new line of business.
- These could be happening: To hedge its technology risk, INPEX may make a small, strategic investment in a DAC technology company or join a research consortium. This would be an early signal of a shift from a purely defensive CCS posture toward embracing a broader range of carbon removal solutions. The start of CO₂ injection at the Kashiwazaki park, which occurred in September 2026, will provide crucial operational data for its domestic strategy.
| Company⇅ | Project Name⇅ | Market Segment⇅ | Location⇅ | Target Capacity (Mtpa)⇅ | 2025 Status / Key Milestones⇅ | Source⇅ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| INPEX (JV) | Darwin CCS Project | Point-Source CCS | Offshore, Northern Territory, Australia | 8.0 – 10.0 | Proposed in November 2025 as a joint venture with TotalEnergies and Woodside. | Plan for Australia’s largest carbon capture project near … ↗ |
| INPEX | Abadi LNG Project (with CCS) | Integrated LNG & CCS | Masela Block, Indonesia | Not specified for CCS component | Commenced Front End Engineering and Design (FEED) on August 4, 2025. | LNG Review August 2025 ↗ |
| INPEX | Bonaparte CCS Project | Point-Source CCS | Bonaparte Basin, Australia | Pre-FEED work underway (April 2025); Environmental referral submitted (October 2025). The project was later withdrawn in Jan 2026. | 2025-26 Northern Territory Economy book ↗ | |
| INPEX (JV) | Metropolitan CCS, LTD. | Point-Source CCS | Tokyo Metropolitan Area, Japan | Feasibility study phase | Joint venture established on April 11, 2025, to begin feasibility studies. | INPEX And Kanto Natural Gas Development Establish … ↗ |
| Occidental (1PointFive) | Stratos | Direct Air Capture (DAC) | Ector County, Texas, USA | 0.50 | Construction underway, on track to begin capturing CO2 in late 2025. Backed by a $1.3B total investment. | Oxy’s $1.3B Texas Stratos DAC facility on track for 2025 … ↗ |
| Source⇅ | Report Date⇅ | Market Segment⇅ | Cost per Tonne of CO2 Captured (USD)⇅ | Key Context/Projections⇅ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Energy Solutions (ESI) | Jul 21, 2026 | Operational DAC | $400 – $600 | Represents the operational cost range for DAC in the 2026 timeframe, highlighting the financial bottleneck. |
| Columbia Business School | Nov 7, 2025 | Operational DAC | $135 – $350 | Notes a wide range for current costs with projections for costs to fall below $100 per ton by 2030. |
| Patsnap (Eureka) | Oct 27, 2025 | Automotive DAC | $100 – $500 | Cost estimates for implementing DAC technology specifically in vehicles. |
| Global CCS Institute | Jul 15, 2025 | Point-Source Capture | $35 – $40 | Competitive cost range for point-source CO2 capture processes, which are significantly cheaper than DAC. |
| NETL (via Stellarix) | Jul 1, 2025 | Point-Source Capture | $40 – $60 | Cost for state-of-the-art capture systems achieving 90-95% CO2 removal from point sources. |
| Date⇅ | Partner(s)⇅ | Market Segment⇅ | Partnership Type⇅ | Key Details⇅ | Source⇅ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 15, 2025 | TotalEnergies, Woodside | Carbon Capture & Storage (CCS) | Joint Venture | Proposed Australia's largest carbon capture facility near Darwin to capture and store 8-10 Mtpa of CO2, primarily from the Ichthys LNG project. | Plan for Australia’s largest carbon capture project near … ↗ |
| Jun 5, 2025 | Osaka Gas Co., Ltd. | Carbon Capture & Utilization (CCU) | Collaboration | Collaboration under a subsidy program to advance carbon capture technologies. | CCS / CCU|Low Carbon Solutions|Services | CHIYODA … ↗ |
| Apr 11, 2025 | Kanto Natural Gas Development Co., Ltd. | Carbon Capture & Storage (CCS) | Joint Venture | Established a new joint venture company named 'Metropolitan CCS, LTD.' to conduct a feasibility study for a CCS project in the Tokyo metropolitan area. | INPEX And Kanto Natural Gas Development Establish … ↗ |
| Feb 14, 2025 | Universities and research institutions | Carbon Capture & Storage (CCS) | Joint Research | Conducting joint research in geology, geophysics, and reservoir engineering to advance CCS technologies. | CCS | INPEX CORPORATION ↗ |
| During 2025 | Nippon Steel | Direct Air Capture (DAC) | Partnership | INPEX lists a partnership with Nippon Steel related to Direct Air Capture in its 2025 Integrated Report. | 03_Integrated Report 2025_Growth Strategy ↗ |
| Forecast Provider⇅ | Market Segment⇅ | 2025 Market Size ($B)⇅ | 2030 Forecast ($B)⇅ | 2033/2034/2035 Forecast ($B)⇅ | CAGR (%)⇅ | Source⇅ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Market Research Future | Overall DAC Market | 0.20 * | 2.35 * | 27.50 | 63.50 | Direct Air Capture Market Size, Share, Trends, Report 2035 ↗ |
| Mordor Intelligence | Overall DAC Market | 0.19 | 2.58 | 34.86 * | 68.32 | Direct Air Capture Market Size, Trends & Share Report 2030 ↗ |
| IMARC Group | Overall DAC Market | 0.13 | 1.44 * | 15.40 * | 60.69 | Direct Air Capture Market Size, Trends & Growth 2034 ↗ |
| Grand View Research | Overall DAC Market | 0.15 | 0.98 * | 3.34 | 46.30 | Direct Air Capture Market Size And Share Report, 2026-2033 ↗ |
| The Business Research Company | Overall DAC Market | 1.36 * | 5.13 | 19.42 * | 30.50 | Direct Air Capture Market Size, Share, Drivers Report 2026-2030 ↗ |
| Project Name⇅ | Location⇅ | Market Segment⇅ | Status / Timeline⇅ | Key Metrics / Capacity⇅ | Source⇅ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kashiwazaki Hydrogen Park | Niigata Prefecture, Japan | Blue Hydrogen / CCUS | Commissioning started June 2025; CO2 injection from Sep 2026 | Japan's first integrated blue H2/ammonia value chain. Production capacity of 100 tonnes/day of hydrogen. | INPEX Launches Japan’s First Blue Hydrogen & Ammonia … ↗ |
| Ichthys LNG Decarbonisation | Bladin Point, Darwin, Australia | LNG / CCS | In development | CCS compression system to capture CO2 from the Ichthys LNG facilities. | CCS activities – INPEX ↗ |
| Metropolitan Area CCS Project | Metropolitan Japan | Carbon Capture & Storage (CCS) | Feasibility study initiated April 2025 | Joint venture to assess large-scale CCS infrastructure for industrial emitters. | INPEX And Kanto Natural Gas Development Establish Joint Venture … ↗ |
| CO2 Capture Testing Facility | Carbon Capture Technology | Completed June 2025 | Testing capacity of 400 Nm3-CO2/h. | CCS / CCU|Low Carbon Solutions|Services | CHIYODA … ↗ |
| Date⇅ | Partner⇅ | Market Segment⇅ | Partnership Type⇅ | Key Details / Value⇅ | Source⇅ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 5, 2025 | Chiyoda Corporation | Carbon Capture Technology | Technology Development | Completed one of the world's largest CO2 capture testing facilities with a capacity of 400 Nm3-CO2/h. | CCS / CCU|Low Carbon Solutions|Services | CHIYODA … ↗ |
| May 18, 2025 | ExxonMobil, JODCO, ADNOC | Upstream Oil & Gas / CCUS | Field Development Plan | Landmark agreement to expand capacity of the Upper Zakum offshore field, strengthening relationships for potential future CCUS projects. | Adnoc deepens energy partnerships with US companies ↗ |
| Apr 11, 2025 | Kanto Natural Gas Development | Carbon Capture & Storage (CCS) | Joint Venture | Established 'Advanced CCS Business Co., Ltd.' to study a metropolitan area CCS project in Japan. | INPEX And Kanto Natural Gas Development Establish Joint Venture … ↗ |
| Forecast Provider⇅ | Market Segment⇅ | 2025 Market Size ($B)⇅ | 2026 Market Size ($B)⇅ | 2030 Forecast ($B)⇅ | 2032 Forecast ($B)⇅ | 2033 Forecast ($B)⇅ | 2034 Forecast ($B)⇅ | 2035 Forecast ($B)⇅ | CAGR (%)⇅ | Source⇅ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Market.us | Global Direct Air Capture | 1.63 * | 2.62 * | 17.80 * | 46.38 * | 74.85 * | 120.81 | 194.99 * | 61.40 | Direct Air Capture Market Size, Share | CAGR of 61.4% ↗ |
| Globe Market Research | Global Direct Air Capture | 0.20 | 0.32 * | 2.22 * | 5.86 * | 9.50 * | 15.39 * | 24.90 | 62 | Direct Air Capture Market Size to Cross USD 24.9 Bn by 2035 ↗ |
| Mordor Intelligence | Global Direct Air Capture | 0.19 | 0.32 * | 2.58 | 7.31 * | 12.30 * | 20.71 * | 34.86 * | 68.32 | Direct Air Capture Market Size, Trends & Share Report 2030 ↗ |
| Grand View Research | Global Direct Air Capture | 0.15 | 0.23 | 1.05 * | 2.24 * | 3.34 | 4.88 * | 7.14 * | 46.30 | Direct Air Capture Market Size And Share Report, 2026-2033 ↗ |
| IMARC Group | Global Direct Air Capture | 0.13 | 0.22 * | 1.40 * | 3.63 * | 5.84 * | 9.38 * | 15.07 * | 60.69 | Direct Air Capture Market Size, Trends & Growth 2034 – IMARC Group ↗ |
| Credence Research | Global Direct Air Capture | 2.45 | 3.18 * | 8.78 * | 11.69 | 15.16 * | 19.67 * | 25.53 * | 29.74 | Direct Air Capture Market Size, Growth, Share and Forecast 2032 ↗ |
| Precedence Research | U.S. Direct Air Capture | 0.05 | 0.08 * | 0.48 * | 1.18 * | 1.85 * | 2.91 * | 6.02 | 56.88 * | Direct Air Capture Market Size, Share and Trends 2026 to 2035 ↗ |
The questions your competitors are already asking
This report covers one angle of carbon capture commercialization. The questions that matter most depend on your work.
- Regulatory status Darwin carbon capture hub
- Cost of integrating carbon capture with existing LNG plants
- Occidental direct air capture offtake agreements
- Japan carbon capture project financing and policy
This report does not answer these. Enki Brief Pro does.
Your question, your angle, your framework. SWOT, PESTL, scenario modelling. The same niche depth, built around the decision your work actually depends on.
Run your first brief in Enki Brief Pro
Related Articles
If you found this article helpful, you might also enjoy these related articles that dive deeper into similar topics and provide further insights.
- Climeworks 2025: DAC Market Analysis & Future Outlook
- Carbon Engineering & DAC Market Trends 2025: Analysis
- E-Methanol Market Analysis: Growth, Confidence, and Market Reality(2023-2025)
- Battery Storage Market Analysis: Growth, Confidence, and Market Reality(2023-2025)
- Climeworks- From Breakout Growth to Operational Crossroads
Erhan Eren
Erhan Eren is the CEO and Co-Founder of Enki, a commercial intelligence platform for emerging technologies and infrastructure projects, backed by Equinor, Techstars, and NVIDIA. He spent almost a decade in oil and gas, first at Baker Hughes leading market intelligence, strategy, and engineering teams, then at AI startup Maana, where he spearheaded commercial strategy to acquire net new accounts including Shell, SLB, and Saudi Aramco. It was across these roles, watching teams stitch together executive briefings from scattered PDFs and Google searches, that the idea for Enki was born. Erhan holds a BS in Aeronautical Engineering from Istanbul Technical University and an MS in Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering from Illinois Institute of Technology. He has spent over 20 years at the intersection of energy, strategy, and technology, and built Enki to give professionals the clarity they need without the analyst-grade budget or timeline.

